Cathy’s Case
The principle of double effects would apply to this case. The principle states that the activity can be morally permissible if it would reduce harmful effects or the benefits of the action are not achieved through evil actions. In this case, the benefits of the breast implant would be beneficial to Cathy since she would become more attractive, but at the same time, she could develop Anesthesia and could also suffer from Hematoma, so it is wise that Cathy comprehends the good and bad effects of breast implant (Scott, 2019). Secondly, the principle of inner freedom would apply to this case. The parents of Cathy would have let her do whatever she wanted to do and what she perceived as right according to her. Allowing her to undergo the breast transplant would stop her from overthinking or mental discomfort, thus experiencing a sense of inner freedom. It would be a thrilling and joyful sensation as if an enormous burden had been taken off her shoulders. Lastly, the principle of well-informed consent would apply in this case. The principle states that people should undertake actions that are consistent with God’s love. Cathy would have remained the way she was because that was the love of God. Therefore, performing a breast Implant would contradict the love of God.
When Cathy comes to the hospital for a breast implant first, I would explain the dangers associated with the action. Then I would advise her to accept herself the way she is since that is God’s want, and she should not alter with the love of God. Being a friend to Cathy, I would advise her not to consider the breast implant and accept herself the way she is. I would try to explain to her that she is beautiful the way she is, so she doesn’t have to undergo surgery. I would also advise her to be patient since, at the age of fourteen, she was too young to have large breasts and that everything has its time. Lastly, I would tell her to wait for a couple of years to grow and mature intellectually and emotionally before making significant choices about modifying her body.
References
Scott Thompson. (2019). Ethical principles of totality. Work – Chron.com. https://work.chron.com/ethical-principles-totality-4478.html
Principles of Catholic Health Care Ethics
Leave a Reply