13 Nursing Conflict Scenarios Examples With Real Solutions

Every nurse has a story about conflict. Maybe it was a patient refusing treatment. Maybe it was a tense exchange with a physician, or a difficult conversation with a worried family member. These are not rare events — they’re part of daily nursing practice. That’s why learning from nursing conflict scenario examples can prepare you to respond with calm and confidence.

Conflict in nursing isn’t about drama — it’s about communication, teamwork, and patient safety. When handled well, conflict can actually strengthen trust and improve care. When ignored, it can damage relationships and put patients at risk.

This guide gives you real-world scenarios, step-by-step scripts, and strategies you can use in clinicals, interviews, or on the job.

💙 Support for Busy Nursing Students

We see you — really see you.

You’re juggling work, classes, and family, and still finding the energy to care for everyone else. That kind of strength deserves support, not burnout. Let our nursing writers step in when life gets too full so you can finally breathe.

Get Help With Your Next Nursing Paper →

100% original work · Nursing-focused writers · Confidential

Common Types of Nursing Conflicts

Conflicts in nursing tend to fall into a few main categories. Recognizing them early helps you respond before problems escalate.

Communication breakdowns – missing details during handoffs, unclear orders, or misunderstandings.
Interpersonal conflicts – disrespect, bullying, or personality clashes between staff.
Patient and family conflicts – refusal of care, anger, or unrealistic expectations.
Resource and staffing conflicts – disagreements about assignments, workloads, or floating.
Ethical dilemmas – end-of-life disputes, autonomy vs. safety, or limited resources.

Each example below shows not only what the conflict looks like but also how to address it in the moment.

Nursing Conflict Scenario Examples

Nurse–Patient Conflicts

Scenario 1: Patient Refuses Medication

Conflict setup: You bring in a blood pressure pill. The patient folds their arms and says, “I don’t want that pill. It makes me feel worse.”
Red flags: Agitation, risk of noncompliance, possible health decline.
Steps to resolve:
1. Stay calm and avoid pushing.
2. Acknowledge their concern.
3. Explain why the medication is needed.
4. Ask open-ended questions about side effects.
5. Involve the provider if refusal continues.
Sample script:
“I hear you. Can you tell me more about what happens when you take it? Let’s talk through what it does for your blood pressure and see if there are options that feel better for you.”

Scenario 2: Disagreement About Pain Medication Timing

Conflict setup: A patient rings the call light 30 minutes before their next pain dose. They say, “You don’t care about my pain.”
Red flags: High emotion, mistrust, risk of unsafe medication use.
Steps to resolve:
1. Show empathy and avoid defensive replies.
2. Explain medication timing clearly.
3. Offer non-medication comfort strategies while they wait.
4. Reassure them you’ll return promptly when the dose is due.
Sample script:
“I can see you’re uncomfortable, and I don’t want you to feel ignored. The next dose is due in 30 minutes. In the meantime, let’s adjust your position and add a warm blanket to help while we wait.”

Nurse–Family Conflicts

Families often carry stress, fear, and frustration into the hospital. Their emotions can spill over, creating conflict with the care team. Here are two common situations and how to handle them.

Scenario 3: Angry Family Member Challenges Care

Conflict setup: You’re checking vitals when a daughter storms in and says, “You’re not looking after my mother enough. She’s being neglected.”
Red flags: High emotion, risk of escalation, loss of trust.
Steps to resolve:
1. Pause and listen without interrupting.
2. Validate their concern — don’t dismiss feelings.
3. Clarify the care being provided.
4. Offer to review the care plan together.
5. Involve the charge nurse if tension continues.
Sample script:
“I hear how worried you are, and I want to reassure you. We check your mom’s vitals every four hours and monitor her closely. Let’s go over her care plan together so you know what’s being done.”

Scenario 4: Disagreement About Visiting Hours

Conflict setup: It’s 10:30 p.m. Visiting hours ended at 9 p.m., but the patient’s son refuses to leave.
Red flags: Policy vs. compassion, rising tension between staff and family.
Steps to resolve:
1. Acknowledge the importance of family presence.
2. Explain the hospital’s policy clearly.
3. Offer alternatives — an early morning visit, a phone call, or video chat.
4. Escalate to security only if necessary.
Sample script:
“I know being here matters to you. The policy is that visiting hours end at nine so patients can rest. Let’s make sure you’re the first to visit in the morning, and we can also set up a phone call before you go tonight.”

Nurse–Physician Conflicts

Nurse–physician interactions can become strained under stress, especially when communication is rushed or respect is missing. Staying professional and using clear frameworks is key.

Scenario 5: Disrespectful Physician Response During a Call

Conflict setup: You call a physician at midnight about a patient with dropping blood pressure. The physician snaps, “Why are you bothering me with this?”
Red flags: Power imbalance, risk of communication breakdown, delayed care.
Steps to resolve:
1. Stay calm and professional — don’t mirror their tone.
2. Use SBAR (Situation, Background, Assessment, Recommendation) to present facts.
3. Keep patient safety at the center.
4. Document the interaction for follow-up if needed.
Sample script:
“Doctor, I understand it’s late, but the patient’s blood pressure dropped to 80/50. I need your guidance. Here’s the assessment so far…”

Scenario 6: Clarifying an Unclear or Unsafe Order

Conflict setup: A physician orders a medication dose that seems unusually high.
Red flags: Patient safety risk, potential medication error.
Steps to resolve:
1. Double-check the order in the chart.
2. Politely request clarification.
3. Support your concern with evidence — standard dosing ranges, policy, or protocol.
4. Involve pharmacy or the charge nurse if not resolved.
Sample script:
“Doctor, I want to clarify the morphine dose. It’s higher than the typical range. Can we confirm if this is correct?”

Nurse–Nurse Conflicts (Lateral Violence / Bullying)

Conflict doesn’t only happen with patients or families. Sometimes it happens between nurses, and these situations can affect morale, trust, and even patient safety.

Scenario 7: Withholding Information During Handoff

Conflict setup: A colleague gives a rushed handoff and leaves out key details about a patient’s oxygen needs. You catch the omission while reviewing the chart.
Red flags: Missed information, safety risk, pattern of neglect.
Steps to resolve:
1. Verify the missing information in the chart.
2. Address the issue directly, calmly, and privately.
3. Use SBAR to clarify and reset expectations.
4. Involve the charge nurse if the behavior repeats.
Sample script:
“I noticed the oxygen settings weren’t included in your handoff. Can we make sure we cover that every time? It’s important for safety.”

Scenario 8: Belittling or Gossip in Front of Others

Conflict setup: A team member mocks your clinical decision in front of the group, leaving you embarrassed.
Red flags: Workplace bullying, lack of respect, toxic culture.
Steps to resolve:
1. Stay calm — don’t react in front of others.
2. Ask to talk privately.
3. Use “I” statements to describe the impact.
4. Document the behavior and involve leadership if it continues.
Sample script:
“When you said that in front of others, I felt disrespected. If you have concerns about my care, I’d prefer we talk one-on-one.”

Interdisciplinary Team Conflicts

Nurses also work closely with other healthcare professionals — physical therapists, dietitians, respiratory therapists, social workers, and more. Different perspectives sometimes create tension.

Scenario 9: Disagreement Between Nurse and Physical Therapist

Conflict setup: A physical therapist wants to ambulate a patient shortly after surgery, but you believe the patient isn’t stable.
Red flags: Differing professional opinions, risk to patient safety, strained teamwork.
Steps to resolve:
1. Share your concerns using patient data (vitals, labs, pain scores).
2. Acknowledge the PT’s expertise and goals.
3. Suggest a compromise — delay until the patient stabilizes, then reassess together.
4. Escalate to the provider if agreement isn’t possible.
Sample script:
“I understand why you want to get them moving early. My concern is that their blood pressure dropped after standing. Can we reassess in an hour and make a plan together?”

Staffing and Assignment Conflicts

Workload distribution can be a sensitive subject. If left unaddressed, it can erode teamwork and create burnout.

Scenario 10: Perceived Unfair Assignment

Conflict setup: A nurse feels they always get the heaviest patient load, while others receive lighter assignments. They bring it up during shift change.
Red flags: Low morale, potential burnout, resentment.
Steps to resolve:
1. Listen to their concern without interrupting.
2. Review assignment criteria — acuity, skill mix, and staffing levels.
3. Explain the reasoning behind the assignments.
4. Explore options such as rotating more complex patients.
5. Share patterns with management if the issue continues.
Sample script:
“I hear your concern. Assignments are based on patient acuity and staff mix. Let’s look at ways to keep the workload balanced so it feels fair for everyone.”

Scenario 11: Refusal to Float to Another Unit

Conflict setup: A nurse is told to float to another unit and refuses, saying, “I don’t feel safe there.”
Red flags: Staffing shortage, possible care gaps, policy concerns.
Steps to resolve:
1. Ask why they feel unsafe — lack of training, unfamiliar environment, or other reasons.
2. Validate their concern but explain the staffing need.
3. Offer support — pairing them with a senior nurse, buddy system, or brief orientation.
4. Document refusal and escalate if it persists.
Sample script:
“I understand you’re uncomfortable. The unit is short-staffed, and your help is needed. I’ll make sure you’re paired with an experienced nurse so you’re supported.”

Ethical and End-of-Life Conflicts

Some of the hardest conflicts nurses face involve ethics and end-of-life care. These situations require sensitivity, neutrality, and respect for patient wishes.

Scenario 12: Patient Wants to Leave AMA (Against Medical Advice)

Conflict setup: A patient insists on leaving the hospital before treatment is complete, despite serious risks.
Red flags: Autonomy vs. safety, legal and ethical tension.
Steps to resolve:
1. Explain the risks clearly and calmly.
2. Document the conversation and the patient’s decision.
3. Involve the provider and charge nurse immediately.
4. Ensure the AMA form is signed before discharge.
Sample script:
“I want to make sure you understand the risks of leaving now. Can I go over them with you so you can make an informed choice?”

Scenario 13: Family Disagrees on End-of-Life Care

Conflict setup: One sibling wants “everything done,” while another supports hospice. Both argue at the bedside.
Red flags: Emotional distress, family tension, risk of non–patient-centered care.
Steps to resolve:
1. Stay neutral — avoid taking sides.
2. Acknowledge both perspectives.
3. Suggest a family meeting with the provider or ethics team.
4. Keep the patient’s wishes at the center of the discussion.
Sample script:
“I can see this is very difficult for your family. The best next step is to bring the care team together so we can focus on what your loved one wanted.”

How to Resolve Nursing Conflicts Effectively

When conflict happens, having a process to fall back on makes it easier to respond. Here’s a simple framework that works in almost any nursing situation:

Recognize the conflict early
- Watch for raised voices, dismissive comments, or repeated refusals.
- Address issues before they spiral.
Use active listening and empathy
- Let the other person share their concern fully.
- Show understanding: “I hear you’re upset about this” often defuses tension.
Apply SBAR (Situation, Background, Assessment, Recommendation)
- Keeps communication structured and clear, especially with physicians.
Stay professional and patient-focused
- Keep the discussion centered on safety and care, not personalities.
- Avoid sarcasm or defensive language.
Escalate when needed
- If no resolution, involve a charge nurse, manager, or ethics team.
Document the conflict and outcome
- Protects you legally and ensures a record if the issue repeats.

Tips for Nursing Students and New Grads

Conflict may feel intimidating at first, but practice builds confidence.

Role-play scenarios with classmates to rehearse responses.
Use STAR (Situation, Task, Action, Result) when describing conflicts in interviews.
Keep a reflection journal after clinicals to track what you noticed and learned.
Seek mentorship from experienced nurses who can model effective communication.
Pause before responding — even a deep breath can reset the tone.

FAQs About Nursing Conflict Scenarios

What are the most common conflict scenarios in nursing?

Patient refusals, angry family members, nurse–physician disagreements, lateral violence, and staffing disputes.

How should a nurse handle an angry family member?

Stay calm, listen, validate, and explain the care plan. Involve leadership if needed.

What’s the difference between feedback and bullying?

Feedback is about performance and given respectfully. Bullying is personal, repeated, and often public.

How do I describe a conflict in a nursing interview?

Use the STAR method. Highlight how you stayed patient-focused and the positive outcome.

Which conflict resolution styles are most common in nursing?

Collaboration and accommodation are most often used. Nurses balance teamwork with patient needs.

Conclusion

Conflict in nursing isn’t a sign that something has gone wrong — it’s part of real-world healthcare. What matters is how you handle it.

From medication refusals to end-of-life disputes, the nursing conflict scenario examples in this guide show that every situation has a structured way forward. By pausing, listening, and responding with clarity, you not only resolve conflict but also build trust and protect the people in your care.

Think of conflict as a skill, not a problem. The more you practice with examples, scripts, and steps, the more confident you’ll feel when the next challenge arises.

Nursing Conflict Scenario Examples: Real Cases, Scripts, and Solutions